Damian Garrido QC, Alicia Collinson and Kate Ferguson successful in the Court of Appeal upholding findings of sexual abuse.


12th March 2019

 

Re. Y & E (Children) [2019] EWCA Civ 206, 21 February 2019.

 

 

 

Damian Garrido QC (leading Elizabeth Walker) representing the children’s mother and Alicia Collinson leading Kate Ferguson representing the local authority successfully argued for the dismissal of an appeal by the father against findings of sexual abuse made by HH Judge Handley sitting at Northampton.

 

 

 

The Court of Appeal accepted their arguments that the deficiencies in the ABE interview process were not so serious as to render the child’s interviews of no or limited evidential value and the judge was entitled to make the findings. The Court agreed with Mr Garrido that a trial judge is entitled to a ‘margin of appreciation’ and findings of facts should not be interfered with unless there are compelling reasons so to do (see Fage UK Ltd v Chobani UK Ltd [2014] EWCA Civ 5). Finally, the Court re-stated the well settled law that the standard of proof in such cases is the balance of probabilities.

 

 

 

The judgment can be found at www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWCA/Civ/2019/206.html

 



Associated Members


London

2 Harcourt Buildings
Temple
London
EC4Y 9DB
Dx 373 LDE
Tel 0207 353 6961

Oxford

Churchill House
3 St Aldate's Courtyard,
38 St Aldate's, Oxford
OX1 1BN
Dx 96453 Oxford 4
Tel 01865 791559

Contact

0207 353 6961
clerks@harcourtchambers.co.uk

 

©2018 Harcourt Chambers
All Rights Reserved