James Dove responded successfully to an appeal of an interim care order


12th Dec 2017 | News


James Dove responded successfully to an appeal of an interim care order in BJ (a child) [2017] CA (Civ Div) before Lord Justices McFarlane, Moylan and Peter Jackson on behalf of a local authority.

The court upheld the decision of HHJ Corbett to separate a mother from her baby at a residential assessment centre. The court confirmed that the test for removal is as set out by Lord Justice Thorpe in Re H [2002] EWCA Civ 1932:

Paragraph 39. “…..In my judgment, the arts 6 and 8 rights of the parents required the judge to abstain from premature determination of their case for the future beyond the final fixture, unless the welfare of the child demanded it. In effect, since removal from these lifelong parents to foster parents would be deeply traumatic for the child, and of course open to further upset should the parents’ case ultimately succeed, that separation was only to be contemplated if B’s safety demanded immediate separation.” 

McFarlane LJ confirmed that ‘immediate’ was an important part of the test. The question remains, what is the situation at the time of the hearing? Does a child need to be immediately separated from their carer or not?


Do you have a similar case?

If you would like some help or advice, talk about a similar matter, call our clerks on 020 7353 6961.

Author

Recent

The test to discharge a special guardianship order (Re M (special guardianship order—leave to apply to discharge))

Ruth Cabeza considers the Court of Appeal’s clarification of the test for an application for leave to apply to...

We are delighted to announce that Anna Yarde has returned from maternity leave

We are delighted to welcome Anna back from maternity leave who is once more focused on her busy practice. Anna...

Mehvish Chaudhry co-authors article which explores the 1980 Hague Convention on Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction and British Overseas Territories

Mehvish Chaudhry has co-authored an article alongside James Netto, Partner at The International Family Law Group, which...

Search